1. Were witches burned in English-speaking countries?

A. No, they were hanged not burned, because witchcraft was a felony. This was also true in North America.

2. Were millions of witches put to death?

A. No, the real number was nearer 50,000 across the whole era and whole known world. Only 2,000 witches were tried in England.

3. What proportion of those tried for witchcraft In England were actually convicted?

A. About 25%

4. Why were so few executed?

A. Judges and jurymen were sceptical about the existence of magical power. Many knew that old women could be persecuted by their neighbours for no reason other than that they were not very attractive!

5. Was the Catholic church particularly harsh on witches?

A. In England Protestant rulers also carried out trials.  Catholicism tended to be blamed for any superstitions so that anti-catholic feelings in England e.g. in Elizabethan times could quickly and easily give rise to renewal of witch persecutions.

6. Who was harder on witches, James I or Elizabeth I.

A. More witches were executed in the last decade of Elizabeth’s reign than under James. Although James was involved in some famous trials when he was in Scotland, by the time he became James I of England he spent more time exposing witchcraft accusations rather than confirming them.

7. Were all witches women?

A. About 10-15% of those executed for witchcraft in England were male.

8. What were the key characteristics of the average witch at this time?

A. Old beggar woman – who asked her neighbours incessantly for charity usually in the form of food.  Also women who took up places of authority in others’ households e.g. looking after new-born babies.

9. Who did more of the accusing, men or women?

A. Women. Much was food related so incidence rose in times of famine. Causing a cow to be stricken (a fairly common accusation) might be, and was, interpreted as mass murder.

10. Were most witches herbalists?

A. Another myth.

Lesson or enquiryHistorical focus
Teaching KS3 history: Early Modern HistoryOverview of Britain, 1500–1750
The execution of Charles I – advising a film directorSource analysis and evaluation
So you think your pupils know about witchcraft in early modern Britain?Challenging misconceptions about witchcraft
Why were so many witches hanged in the 16th and 17th centuries?Causation and evaluating explanations
How ‘Bloody’ was Mary Tudor?Interpretations and historical judgement
Why did sons kill fathers in the English Civil War? The Verneys enquiryCivil War loyalties and divided families
Religious change in the 16th century: did they do what they were told?The Reformation and responses to religious change
Parchment in the flames – the World Turned Upside DownUsing sources to explore the aftermath of the Civil War
Did the Great Fire really end the Great Plague of 1665?Testing explanations using statistics and maps
English Civil War enquiry: was the last year of the war more about sieges than pitched battles?Using data to investigate Civil War fighting
Starter activity on religious changes in the reign of Edward VIInterpreting images of religious change
Having lost his parliament, then his throne, why did Charles I have to lose his head?Prioritising causes of Charles I’s execution
Cromwell: a reputation deserved?Evaluating interpretations of Cromwell
Early Modern Britain 1500–1750: Editor’s PencilOverview and identifying historical errors
Were Cromwell’s actions at Drogheda as brutal as we’ve been led to believe? Ketchup on the wallsEvaluating evidence and interpretations of Drogheda
Share